My Grandma’s Bagel, Now Vegan

Bagel and Lox, all vegan!

Okay, the title of my post may look like a typo, but my Grandma Janet always spoke about bagel as a singular term, never plural. She was “making bagel,” never bagels. I don’t think I ever had store-bought bagel growing up, Grandma’s were just that good! And when I did have one from the store, it just wasn’t right—Grandma’s were lighter but had a crisp crust that crunched when you bit into it, and they were so much more flavorful. There was nothing else like Grandma Janet’s bagel! When I went through her old recipe card file box years later, I discovered that there were no less than five copies of her bagel recipe in it—that’s how important bagel was!

Grandma Janet Christmas 2012

Uploaded by Trimazing! Health & Lifestyle Coaching on 2019-07-19.

I’m not sure where Grandma got her bagel recipe. Her mother, my Great-Grandmother Ida, was a cake baker, so it’s possible that she got the recipe from her. My mom shared that her Grandma Ida was divorced and deaf, so she could not work outside the home. There was no welfare at that time, or she would have qualified, and the only way she could make any money to support herself was to bake cakes in her little one-bedroom apartment in Monroe, Louisiana with a teeny, tiny kitchen. She sold the cakes mostly to people from her synagogue and people in the community who knew her.

My Grandma Janet and mom, Linda, when they were living in Japan after World War II. My grandfather was stationed there to run the US Army Dental Corps.

Like a lot of my old family recipes, bagel was not vegan or oil-free, so I’ve updated Grandma’s amazing recipe. While delicious, her bagel was originally made with eggs and Mazola oil (she was particular about the type of oil), neither of which I eat. As I’ve been successful subbing out oil with winter squash purée in other baked goods (my Sourdough English Muffins, for example), I did the same with the bagel recipe. Instead of eggs, I use flax egg, which is ground flax seed mixed with water. And it works! You don’t even taste the squash and the flax meal gives a great textural component.

Making Bagel

My grandma passed away in 2013, but I was fortunate enough to have her teach me how to make her bagel when I was a teen. Luckily I’d made some notes on an old recipe card of hers, otherwise I would have been lost from her recipe, which only listed ingredients, not directions on how to make them! Making bagel isn’t hard, there just are some specific steps to take in order for them to be bagel and not a roll with a hole in it!

It is important to use bread flour for this recipe.

First and foremost, you need to use bread flour in this recipe, not all-purpose flour. Bread flour has more protein in it, i.e. gluten, which helps give this bagel more body and structure. You’ll need between 5-6 cups of bread flour for this recipe.

Combine warm water, sugar, and dry yeast in a mixer or food processor bowl. Wait until the yeast mixture is all foamy and frothy before proceeding.

Blooming the yeast.

Next add the squash purée and additional water to your mixer with a dough hook or food processor fitted with a bread blade. Blend to combine. Add the flour in several batches and mix until a dough forms. Add more flour if the dough is sticky and then knead for 8 minutes to develop the gluten.

Kneading the dough in a stand mixer.

I like to finish the kneading on a lightly floured surface to shape the dough up into a nice ball.

Finished kneaded dough.

Put the kneaded shaped dough into a bowl, cover with a light towel, and place in a warm place to rise for an hour. I find that my oven with the light on makes a perfect proofing box—just make sure that you don’t turn the oven on while the dough is in there rising!

After this first rise, punch the dough down and remove from the bowl onto a working surface.

Punch down the raised dough.

With a pastry scraper or knife, cut the dough into twelve 100-gram pieces. Cover them with a towel so they don’t dry out while you form the bagel.

100 gram chunk of dough. I love the large bits of flax seed in this dough!

Now it’s time to form the bagel. You start by rolling a piece of dough into a log. You want it to be long enough to go around your hand to make a regular-sized bagel.

Log-rolling the bagel dough.

Take the roll of dough and wrap it around your hand at the level of your knuckles, bringing the ends together. Pinch the ends of the dough well to seal. Then roll the circle of dough on your working surface to smooth and shape the bagel. The bagel will go through a second rise, so make sure to make an exaggerated hole size or else your bagel will close when the dough puffs up.

Wrap log-rolled dough around your hand (left), pinch the ends together well (center), and roll on the surface to shape the bagel (right).

Place the formed bagel on a baking tray covered with a towel lightly sprinkled with flour. Repeat this process for all twelve pieces of dough. Cover with a light towel and let rise for an hour.

Formed bagel.

Preheat your oven to 375˚F (remember to pull your raising bagel trays out of the oven before you do this, if you’re using the oven as a proof box!). Set a large pot of water to boil. Add salt to the water once it boils so that it tastes like sea water.

Get two baking trays ready with a silicone baking sheet on each. The silicone baking sheet is important! If you place the boiled bagel directly on the baking tray it will adhere itself to the metal like glue and you’ll have a difficult, if not impossible, time removing it after baking, tearing the bagel in the process.

Bagel after second rise. See how much smaller the holes are?

Drop bagels three at a time into the boiling salted water. Boil them for 30 seconds, flip over, and boil the other side for 30 seconds longer. Pull them out of the water with a slotted spoon and place on the prepared baking sheet. Repeat for remaining bagel.

Boiling bagel in salted water.

Remove to tray for baking.

Sometimes your bagel will come apart at the seam…don’t worry…that’s a C is for Cindy bagel, and a truly special one as they taste the BEST!

A Cindy bagel!

If you want sprinkles on your bagel, now is the time to do it. The bagel is soft and sticky after boiling, so seeds, spices, salt, etc. will adhere nicely to the top. You can make an everything sprinkle to use, if you’d like.

Sprinkle before baking.

Now pop your trays into the preheated oven and bake for 30 minutes. The bagel will get golden brown. Remove from the trays and cool on a wire rack.

Beautifully baked bagel.

Now you’re ready to enjoy your freshly made bagel! Serve as desired, maybe toasted with your favorite vegan cream cheese, perhaps some carrot lox, some jam, or maybe just plain. They toast marvelously! Keep them in a sealed container, like a cookie tin, or paper bag for several days or freeze them up to three months…like if you can wait that long to eat them!

These are the best bagel on the planet, I promise you. Good, and good for you, I’m certain they would have my grandmother’s seal of approval if she was still with us. I know she watches down on me when I make them and that she is smiling. She would be thrilled to no end knowing that others are enjoying making them too, so please give them a try!

This post is Day 6 of VeganMoFo (Vegan Month of Food) 2019, with a new blog post every day for the month of August. Check out these other posts you may have missed from last week:

Day 1—Welcome to VeganMoFo 2019!

Day 2—In the Room Where it Happens—Trimazing! Kitchen Tour

Day 3—Trilby’s—Santa’s Favorite Cookie!

Day 4—Coconut’s About You—Caramel-Topped Oatmeal Cake

Day 5—Accidentally Vegan—Pesto Palmiers

Have you entered to win my giveaway yet?

Fast & Easy Vegan Cookbook Giveaway

I’ll draw one winner August 21, 2019 for JL Fields’ new Fast & Easy Vegan Cookbook, before you can even buy it online or in stores!

You want this cookbook! It brings a new selection of fresh meals to your table, pronto! From one-pot to pressure cooker, choose your favorite cooking method―without being held hostage for hours in your kitchen. It includes 100 quick and tasty vegan recipes, plus tips for ingredient substitution and other easy customizations, and handy labels for gluten-free, nut-free, oil-free, or soy-free diets.

So hurry and enter by August 20th. Open to U.S. residents only.

JL Fields Fast and Easy Cookbook Giveaway

You can also pre-order the book or order it after the contest is over on Amazon.

Print Pin
5 from 1 vote

Homemade Bagel

You'll never buy bagel at the store again!
Course Bread
Cuisine Jewish, Nut-Free, Soy-Free
Author Cindy Thompson, MS, NBC-HWC | Trimazing! Health & Lifestyle Coaching


  • 1 package dry yeast 2¼ tsp
  • ½ tsp sugar
  • 1 cup warm water

Flax Egg

  • 3 tbsp ground flax seed
  • ¼ cup water

Wet Ingredients

  • ½ cup pureed winter squash
  • ½ cup warm water

Dry Ingredients

  • 6 cups bread flour divided


  • water
  • salt


  • Combine yeast, sugar, and warm water and let sit until bubbly.
  • Make the flax egg by combining flax meal and water.
  • In a mixer with a dough hook or food processor with the bread blade, combine yeast mixture, flax egg, winter squash, and water. Mix to blend.
  • Gradually add 5 cups of bread flour. Add a little more flour if the dough is still sticky and knead about 8 minutes to develop the gluten.
  • Place dough into a bowl, cover with a light towel, and place in a warm spot to rise 1 hour. I simply turn on the oven light (with oven turned off) and put the covered bowl in there—it's the perfect proofing temperature.
  • After dough has risen, remove from the oven, punch down, and cut into 12 100g pieces. Cover pieces with a towel while shaping individual bagel so the dough doesn't dry out while you are working.
  • Roll piece of dough into a log shape and then wrap it around your hand. Pinch the ends together well and roll the O-shaped dough with your other hand or on the counter, using your wrapped hand as a form.
  • Place the formed bagel on a cookie sheet lined with lightly floured cloth. Repeat with remaining dough.
  • Cover formed bagel and let rise 1 hour.
  • Heat oven to 375°F. If using a baking stone, preheat oven with stone.
  • Bring a pot of water to boil. Add salt to taste once water is boiling, it should taste like seawater.
  • Add 3 bagel at a time to the boiling salt water. Boil 30 seconds, then flip and boil another 30 seconds. Remove boiled bagel to baking sheet covered with a silicone baking sheet. Repeat with remaining bagel.
  • If you want sprinkles like poppy seeds, sesame seeds, onion flakes, etc., add them now so they stick to the top.
  • Bake 30 minutes, either removing prepared bagel to a preheated baking stone or on the baking sheet.
  • Remove from oven and cool on a wire rack.


Do you like this post?  Please share....


  1. Sara Young on August 6, 2019 at 6:26 pm

    These look amazing! We love bagels so I want to try these to get away from the bagged plastic!!!
    I love all your photos of the work in progress too!

    • Cindy Thompson, Trimazing! Vegan Lifestyle & Health Coaching on August 7, 2019 at 1:43 pm

      Thank you so much, Sara! I hope you do try them. Hopefully the photos help illustrate how to form and prep them!

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating

If you liked this post, you might like one of these:

Subscribe to the Trimazing Blog

Receive occasional blog posts in your email inbox.

Subscribe to the Trimazing Blog

Receive occasional blog posts in your email inbox.